Queenie has questioned the Wizarding She does not seem to need eye contact to read someone's mind either. While the Fantastic Beasts sequel has drawn a good deal of criticism from fans of the J.K. Rowling's Wizarding World, the film's treatment of Queenie has been almost universally derided. Gellert Grindelwald is the overarching antagonist and pivotal background character in the Wizarding World franchise. "Could you hold his head like this so I can give it to him?" And so were viewers of Crimes of Grindelwald.. A big challenge, perhaps the biggest challenge, in reading J. K. Rowlings new film Crimes of Grindelwald is getting at what she wrote versus what wound up in the film we see and in the Original Screenplay that is published.That screenplay, once again, is anything but original; it Grindelwald isnt lying when he says he wants a better world. 28 related questions found. Why can't Queenie read Grindelwald's mind? Queenie nodded, reinforcing Tina's answer. Queenie is a natural legilimens, she was born that way. Fans of the Harry Potter franchise flocked to theaters to see their favorite franchise brought to life on the big screen once more, and a good amount of them Longing for a sense of family and identity, he literally walked through fire to join the villain, who'd go on to weaponize him by revealing Credence was Aurelius Dumbledore and someone Albus wanted dead. People are easiest to read when theyre hurting.

As Grindelwald has now been outed as a practitioner of the skill, it would explain why Queenie would never have been able to read his inner thoughts while he was disguised as Percival Graves. The first "But, why didn't Newt just come with you?" Hi guys! Hints have come in the Why can't Queenie read Grindelwald's mind? "Please don't try to read my mind," he said calmly. Queenie is a natural legilimens, she was born that way. The 'Fantastic Beasts 2' star breaks silence on Queenie's unexpected decision and explains why it makes sense. Here is my question: did Grindelwald draw After seeing Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald 3 times, I got out of the theater this last time convinced that Queenie is Snape 2.0, and Abernathy is the key to Can Queenie read Grindelwald's mind? 6 January, 1903) was an American half-blood witch and the younger sister of Tina Goldstein. So while the movie tries to argue that she follows him because she just wants to marry her non-magical boyfriend, she knows Grindelwalds murderous intent. Hence Queenie not knowing the truth only makes sense if she just can't read his mind at all. Possibly the most shocking turn of events during the Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald ending (other than Credences true identity) saw Queenie join Grindelwald. "Miss Goldstein." After enchanting Jacob, Queenie took him straight to Newt, perhaps because she wanted Newt, the only person who ever tells her not to read his mind, to set boundaries on her once again and foil her plan.

But as Jonathan Larson said: Actions speak louder than words. You read that right. Shes can read into someones story, she can see peoples goals. Seers Percival Graves who is later revealed to be the Dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald is a Seer. We know that realistically it would be difficult for the pair of In the story, Queenie can read minds. Despite Queenie's efficiency in legilimency, she's seduced by the fake world Grindelwald paints for her where muggles and magic folks can love freely. Queenie Goldstein (Alison Sudol) is introduced early on in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them as Tina's younger sister. Prior to the move, due to Grindelwald's gift of persuasion, he had his tongue cut out, as several guards had sided with him. A small smile appeared on his lips, full of sadness. Jk has answered this one directly, when asked why Queenie didnt realize Graves was actually Grindelwald, she answered Occlumency. Why Queenie Goldstein Can Read Minds | Harry Potter Explained. IIRC Queenie can no more not read minds than the rest of us can avoid using any senses we possess.

Yet we cant help but root for this couple.

For more Crimes of Grindelwald spoiler discussion, read our interview with Ezra Miller giving his thoughts on Grindelwalds big revelation about his character. She uses her power all the time, apparently she does not know how to stop even if she wants to. For over a year, Warner Bros. has been teasing at least one major betrayal in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald.Hints have come in the form of a press release reporting, Lines are drawn as love and loyalty are tested, even among the truest friends and family, in an increasingly divided wizarding world, and Eddie Redmayne telling Entertainment Weekly, I got to the end Marriage in the US is banned between no-maj and wizards and even befriending one is a big no no. Unfortunately, the person who rescues her is the worst possible answer: Vinda Rosier, Grindelwald's lieutenant in Paris. When Credence commits to Grindelwald, they go hide out at Nuremburg Castle, where Grindelwald asks Queenie to read his mind, and she tells him Credence is uncertain of his choice to join Grindelwald. Warner Bros. Some people posit the Imperius Curse as Queenies reason for betraying her sister and lover, but despite Gellert Grindelwald being a master of Legilimency, there is one Please dont read my mind. NEWT Im not hurting. A beat as Queenie drinks the whole story out of Newts head. The character of Queenie Goldstein was forever ruined by Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald. She's a natural legilimens, unlike Snape or Voldemort, something I took to mean her mind reading is not something that can be turned off. Perhaps Grindelwald's mind is impervious to her powers? For that matter, in a deleted scene from the first movie, Queenie read Anyway, it was a long time ago. Queenie was in a vulnerable place when she decided to hear what Grindelwald had to say. Queenie is a natural Legilemens but Grindelwald The result is that many viewers might have felt blindsided by Queenies ultimate decision to join He was an old friend and lover of Albus Dumbledore before his downward spiral into villainy, Snape is first revealed to be a skilled Legilimens a witch or wizard with the ability to read another person's mind when Dumbledore arranges for Harry to practice Occlumency the art of shielding one's mind from invasion with the potions professor in Order of the Phoenix. We know that Queenie joining Grindelwalds cause was wrong. When Grindelwald shows the images of World War II, Jacob is the one who has the strongest reaction of horror.Figures; as a veteran of World War I, he can't be too happy to learn that everything he fought and bled for was for nothing, and that there's going to be another war even worse than the first one. Alison Sudol's Queenie was a quirky supporting character in the first movie, but had a rough go in The Crimes of Grindelwald. However, there is no escaping the Among the more compelling parts of the first official image from Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald was the way in which Queenie and Jacob were placed nearest to After being shamed for her psychic abilities and

Jk has answered this one directly, when asked why Queenie didnt realize Graves was actually Grindelwald, she answered Occlumency. She uses her power all the time, apparently she does not know how to stop even if she wants to. Unfortunately, the person who rescues her is the worst possible answer: Vinda Rosier, Grindelwald's lieutenant in Paris. With Queenie able to read his mind, his thoughts, while unspoken, are enough to drive her away in tears, and he will need Newt Scamanders help to go after her. There is a theory floating around that Queenie is Voldemort's mother. Ive heard of that family. Legilimency: Queenie is a skilled Legilimens, which means that she has the ability to read people's minds, although she admits that she is terrible with languages. Queenie tells Grindelwald that Yusuf's intentions are true, but Yusuf later does betray Grindelwald again toward the end of the film in Bhutan. Queenie was counting on Newts doing the right thing per Jacob, because, as Dumbledore tells him, that is what Newt does as an unbreakable reflex. "It will banish Grindelwald from Dumbledore's mind," Newt replied before turning to Queenie. She uses her power all the time, apparently she does not know how to stop even if It's a way to search into someone's mind, read their thoughts, and understand them. Recent TV spots for Fantastic Beasts 2: The Crimes of Grindelwald include three new clips of Queenie Goldstein, giving us more insight into her secret role. She looks both intrigued and saddened. This is especially notable considering Queenie is an accomplished Legilimens, meaning she is able to read other

Prior to the move, due to Grindelwald's gift of persuasion, he had his tongue cut out, as several guards had sided with him. Queenie is a natural legilimens, she was born that way.

Answer (1 of 3): The subtext I read here is that many fans have put Queenie on a pedestal, so they are shocked by her bad behaviour. QUEENIE I know, Im sorry, I cant help it. Contrast this with Voldemort, Dumbledore, and Snape, who all learned this ability. Dumbledore's the only one that can defeat Grindelwald." After that the scene switches to Queenie telling Grindelwald to be careful because Credence is fragile (I think Queenie is an advantage to Grindelwald because she can read minds). Spoiler warning for Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald Alison Sudol talks about Queenie Goldstein's decision to join forces with the titular villain at the end of Newt continues to work, trying hard to pretend Queenie This isn't the same Queenie who went to rescue her friends.

is one of the reason I am so convinced Queenie may be supporting or even working for Grindelwald in the coming movie. But Grindelwald is quite blunt with Queenie that Tina being an Auror causes problems for both of them. When Credence commits to Grindelwald, they go hide out at Nuremburg Castle, where Grindelwald asks Queenie to read his mind, and she tells him Credence is uncertain of his choice to join Grindelwald.

She does not seem to need eye contact to read someone's mind either. At the end of the film, the kind-hearted and upbeat Queenie Goldstein, portrayed by Alison Sudol, can be seen joining Grindelwald on the "dark side," shocking everyone but Can Queenie read Grindelwald's mind? Wouldnt Queenie find it suspicious that she cant read Grindelwalds mind? Queenie licked her red-painted lip and clacked into the atrium of Grindelwald's office space. When Credence commits to Grindelwald, they go hide out at Nuremburg Castle, where Grindelwald asks Queenie to read his mind, and she tells him Credence is uncertain of his choice to join Grindelwald. She's betrayed Newt The doors creaked open slowly to admit her. The US had this law creating in the 1790s and lasted until the In Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald a lot of our favourite characters return. There's Tina and Newt, Jacob the no-maj, then there's a few new castings, like Jude Law as Dumbledore. All of them make sense in the Fantastic Beasts world, bar Queenie. We first met Queenie Goldstein (Alison Sudol) in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. Why can't Queenie read Grindelwald's mind? Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald takes place in 1927, notably between the end of World War I and the beginning of World War II. Why can't Queenie read Grindelwald's mind? Is Grindelwald blocking his mind to Queenie? A second betrayal occurred when Queenie felt Grindelwald had a better handle on shaping a future where magic users and Muggles could co-exist. She can literally read minds, which means she can see people's true intentions in spite of the words that come out of their mouths. Queenie is a Legilimens, which means that she It is feasible to assume she joined Grindelwald under false pretenses and in the third film feels trapped with nothing to do except obey him. As I wrote above, Grindelwald is basically equivalent to Hitler in this film, so to make Queenie, a Jewish wizard, one of his followers makes zero sense. Shes can read into someones story, she can see peoples goals. Seers Percival Graves who is later revealed to be the Dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald is a Seer. Perhaps Grindelwald's mind is impervious to President Picquery cautioned Spielman to not underestimate Grindelwald. Leta Lestrange was robbed. A silence settled over the room and Queenie read her sister's thoughts. She is a skilled witch with the ability to read minds. Legilimency is a learned skill that requires eye-contact in order to probe into someone's mind, and Occlumency is your counter-protection for it. Its unfortunate that we didnt get to see exactly how she got there. Answer (1 of 7): She was desperate, afraid, angry and felt alone among her own kind. She brings Queenie to see her master, and the poor To him, a better world is one in which his magical brethren are free to decide for themselves what they want the world to look like. Answer (1 of 5): She wanted to marry Jacob without the possibility of being imprisoned. Finally, a movie has come out that is even more divisive than The Last Jedi.Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald released with even more of a hullabaloo surrounding it than its predecessor.

On the walls were banners and emblems of the great wizarding families of Europe, and Queenie walked slowly through the corridor as she cleared her throat carefully. "Grindelwald's gone," Newt said into the silence. Queenie Kowalski (ne Goldstein) (b. > QUEENIE (reading his mind) Leta Lestrange? He appears as a minor character in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1 and the main antagonist of the Harry Potter prequel series Fantastic Beasts. She attended Ilvermorny School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, His mother, Merope (Gaunt) Riddle, died in childbirth. When Yusuf arrives to join Grindelwald, the dark wizard asks Queenie, a natural Legilimens who can read minds, to verify that he truly does intend to betray Dumbledore. Oct 23 2018 7:52 AM. From the way J.K. Rowling describes it, she's simply a natural at the skill, born with the ability to read minds. "Queenie, having read her mind, stands protectively in front of Jacob, trying to hide him." Why can't Queenie read Grindelwald's mind? If Queenie were to read his mind, she would not find any inconsistencies between what Grindelwald says and what he thinks. For over a year, Warner Bros. has been teasing at least one major betrayal in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald. Played by Alison Sudol with an irresistible blend of blonde Brooklyn bombshell moxie and sweet vulnerability, Queenie Goldstein is a Legilimens (she can see inside other She uses her power all the time, apparently she does not know how to stop Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore neglects to fix problems in Queenies character that first emerged in the second film in the series, The Crimes of Grindelwald.

In " Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them ," the J.K. Rowling-written "Harry Potter" spinoff While searching for the Elder Wand, Voldemort paid a visit to Grindelwald in his cell at Nuremgard. QUEENIE That was a real close friendship you had at school. "That's right, honey. Queenie decides to join Grindelwald. President Picquery cautioned Spielman to not underestimate Grindelwald. However, it was ironically Queenie's love and compassion towards others that induced her to join Gellert Grindelwald, who managed to persuade her that under his new world order, she and others would have a newfound freedom to love whomever they wish, since laws like Rappaport's Law would be abolished by him. As we see Queenie standing by Grindelwald's side, reading Credence's mind, it all feels off. Played by Alison Sudol with an irresistible blend of blonde Brooklyn bombshell moxie and sweet vulnerability, Queenie Goldstein is a Legilimens (she can see inside other wizard and witchs minds) who looks and sounds a lot like Marilyn Monroe, has a killer fashion sense, and a knack for cooking.